Litigating Trusts: How to Dispute Trust Distribution or Trustee Decisions
Trusts are powerful estate planning tools designed to manage and distribute assets according to a grantor’s wishes. However, disputes over trust distributions or trustee decisions can arise, leading to complicated litigation.
In Kansas, trust litigation is governed by state statutes, primarily the Kansas Uniform Trust Code (KUTC), as well as common law principles.
Our firm can help you explore the process of litigating trusts in Kansas, focusing on how to dispute trust distributions or trustee decisions, the legal grounds for such disputes, procedural considerations, and practical steps for beneficiaries or interested parties.
Below, the discussion is structured to provide a comprehensive guide for those navigating trust disputes, whether as a beneficiary, trustee, or legal representative. Our trust lawyer in Overland Park, Kansas, can help you through this process.
A Breakdown of Trusts and Common Disputes
A trust is a fiduciary relationship in which a trustee holds and manages assets for the benefit of designated beneficiaries according to the terms of the trust document. Trusts in Kansas can be revocable or irrevocable, and they may serve various purposes, such as asset protection, tax planning, or providing for minor or incapacitated beneficiaries.
Disputes over trusts often arise due to disagreements about how the trust is administered or how assets are distributed. Common issues include:
Breach of fiduciary duty: A trustee fails to act in the best interests of the beneficiaries, engages in self-dealing, or mismanages trust assets.
Improper distributions: Beneficiaries believe distributions were made incorrectly, unfairly, or in violation of the trust terms.
Ambiguity in trust terms: The trust document is unclear, leading to differing interpretations of the grantor’s intent.
Lack of capacity or undue influence: Claims that the grantor lacked mental capacity or was coerced when creating or amending the trust.
Trustee misconduct: Allegations of fraud, embezzlement, or failure to provide required accountings.
Removal of trustee: Beneficiaries seek to remove a trustee for incompetence, hostility, or other reasons.
In Kansas, the KUTC, codified in K.S.A. 58a-101 et seq., provides the legal structure for trust administration and litigation. Understanding this is critical for anyone seeking to dispute trust distributions or trustee decisions.
Legal Grounds for Disputing Trust Distributions or Trustee Decisions
To initiate trust litigation in Kansas, a party must have standing and a valid legal basis for the dispute. Below are the primary grounds for challenging trust distributions or trustee actions.
Breach of Fiduciary Duty
Trustees in Kansas owe beneficiaries several fiduciary duties under K.S.A. 58a-801 et seq., including:
Duty of loyalty: Acting solely in the beneficiaries’ interests and avoiding conflicts of interest.
Duty of prudence: Managing trust assets with care, skill, and caution.
Duty to inform and account: Providing beneficiaries with regular accountings and information about trust administration.
Duty to administer in good faith: Following the trust’s terms and acting in accordance with the grantor’s intent.
A breach occurs when a trustee violates these duties, such as by making unauthorized distributions, favoring one beneficiary over another, or mismanaging investments. For example, if a trustee distributes trust assets to a non-beneficiary or uses trust funds for personal gain, beneficiaries can sue for breach of fiduciary duty.
Violation of Trust Terms
Trustees must adhere strictly to the terms of the trust document. If a trustee makes distributions that contradict the trust’s instructions—such as distributing assets to the wrong beneficiary or at the wrong time—beneficiaries can challenge the action. Courts in Kansas prioritize the grantor’s intent, as expressed in the trust document, when resolving such disputes.
Lack of Capacity or Undue Influence
Challenges to the validity of a trust often arise when beneficiaries believe the grantor was not mentally competent or was unduly influenced when creating or amending the trust. Under Kansas law, a grantor must have testamentary capacity, meaning they understand the nature of their assets, the beneficiaries, and the disposition they are making.
Undue influence occurs when a third party exerts pressure that overcomes the grantor’s free will, often involving coercion or manipulation.
Fraud or Misrepresentation
If a trustee engages in fraudulent conduct, such as concealing assets, falsifying accountings, or misrepresenting the trust’s terms, beneficiaries can seek legal remedies. Fraud claims may also target the creation of the trust if the grantor was deceived into signing the document.
Improper Trust Administration
Trustees must follow procedural requirements, such as providing annual accountings (K.S.A. 58a-813) and obtaining court approval for certain actions. Failure to comply can lead to disputes, particularly if beneficiaries believe the trustee’s actions harmed the trust or its beneficiaries.
Standing to Sue
Under K.S.A. 58a-103, only “interested persons” have standing to initiate trust litigation. This typically includes:
Beneficiaries (current or remainder).
Trustees or co-trustees.
The grantor (if the trust is revocable).
Creditors or other parties with a legitimate interest, in limited circumstances.
Determining standing is a critical first step, as courts will dismiss claims brought by parties without a legal interest in the trust.
Procedural Steps for Litigating Trusts in Kansas
Litigating a trust dispute in Kansas involves several procedural steps, from pre-litigation considerations to court proceedings. Below is a roadmap for navigating the process.
1. Review the Trust Document
The trust document is the cornerstone of any dispute. It outlines the grantor’s intent, the trustee’s powers, and the beneficiaries’ rights. Reviewing the document with a trust lawyer is essential to identify violations or ambiguities that form the basis of the claim. Key provisions to examine include:
Distribution instructions.
Trustee powers and limitations.
Provisions for trustee removal or replacement.
Dispute resolution clauses (e.g., mandatory arbitration).
2. Gather Evidence
Strong evidence is critical to substantiate claims. Relevant documents and information may include:
The trust document and any amendments.
Trustee accountings and financial records.
Correspondence between the trustee and beneficiaries.
Medical records (for capacity claims).
Witness statements (for undue influence claims).
If the trustee has failed to provide required accountings, beneficiaries can petition the court to compel disclosure under K.S.A. 58a-813.
3. Attempt Informal Resolution
Before filing a lawsuit, parties should consider informal resolution methods, such as negotiation or mediation. Many trust disputes can be resolved without costly litigation, especially if the trustee is willing to address concerns or clarify misunderstandings. Mediation is particularly effective in preserving family relationships, which are often strained in trust disputes.
4. File a Petition in Probate Court
Trust litigation in Kansas typically occurs in the district court’s probate division, as trusts are subject to the court’s equitable jurisdiction. The process begins with filing a petition outlining the claims, such as:
A request to remove a trustee (K.S.A. 58a-706).
A claim for breach of fiduciary duty.
A challenge to the trust’s validity.
A request for a court-ordered accounting or distribution.
The petition must identify the legal grounds, the relief sought, and the parties involved. Kansas courts may require notice to all interested persons, including beneficiaries and co-trustees. A trust lawyer could help file this petition.
5. Discovery and Pre-Trial Proceedings
Once the petition is filed, the case enters the discovery phase, during which parties exchange documents, depose witnesses, and gather additional evidence. Discovery can be contentious in trust litigation, as trustees may resist disclosing financial records or communications. Beneficiaries may need to file motions to compel compliance.
Pre-trial proceedings may also include motions to dismiss, summary judgment, or temporary injunctions to prevent further distributions pending resolution of the case.
6. Trial and Remedies
If the dispute proceeds to trial, the court will evaluate evidence, hear testimony, and interpret the trust document. Kansas courts aim to uphold the grantor’s intent while verifying fairness to beneficiaries. Possible remedies include:
Removal of the trustee: If the trustee’s actions justify removal under K.S.A. 58a-706.
Surcharge: Ordering the trustee to repay the trust for losses caused by misconduct.
Reformation or termination: Modifying or terminating the trust if its purpose is no longer achievable (K.S.A. 58a-410 et seq.).
Invalidation of the trust: If the court finds the trust was created under fraud, undue influence, or lack of capacity.
Equitable relief: Such as ordering proper distributions or enjoining further trustee actions.
7. Appeals
If a party disagrees with the court’s decision, they may appeal to the Kansas Court of Appeals or, in rare cases, the Kansas Supreme Court. Appeals must be based on legal errors, such as misinterpretation of the trust or improper application of the law.
Litigating a trust dispute in Kansas involves a structured process of reviewing the trust document, gathering evidence, attempting informal resolution, filing a petition in probate court, traversing discovery and pre-trial proceedings, pursuing trial remedies, and potentially appealing the decision.
This is done all while adhering to the Kansas Uniform Trust Code and equitable principles to uphold the grantor’s intent and protect beneficiary rights. Our trust lawyer at Heartland Estate Law in Overland Park, Kansas, can help you through this process.
Contact a Trust Lawyer
If you're in need of an experienced trust layer, be sure to reach out to Heartland Estate Law. We serve clients in Overland Park and Philippsburg, Kansas. Contact us today to get started